The High Court in Mukono has nullified the election of Ntenjeru County South Member of Parliament Fred Baseke and ordered a fresh poll after establishing that declaration of results forms from three polling stations in Kayunga District contained forged signatures of presiding officers.
In a judgment delivered on November 20, 2026, Justice Philip W. Mwaka ruled that the irregularities in the transmission and tallying of results from the three polling stations constituted electoral non-compliance that substantially affected the outcome of the January 15 parliamentary election.
The affected polling stations are Nakirubi Trading Centre (A-K), Nazigo Town Secondary School (NAMPE-Z) and Bukasa Church of Uganda Primary School (A-NAJ), all located in Kangulumira Sub-county, Kayunga District.
The judge consequently set aside Baseke’s election, declared the parliamentary seat vacant and directed the Electoral Commission (EC) to organise a fresh election. The commission was also ordered to pay the petitioner’s legal costs.
“The election for directly elected Member of Parliament for Ntenjeru County South Constituency held on the 15th day of January, 2026 was not validly conducted and is hereby set aside,” Justice Mwaka ruled.
Baseke, who was seeking to retain the constituency seat, was declared winner with 14,573 votes against 13,962 obtained by his closest challenger, former MP Patrick Kayongo Nsanja, giving him a narrow majority of 611 votes.
Other candidates in the race included Mukiibi Badiru, who polled 2,209 votes, Lilwaana Muzamilu with 395, Nakanwagi Florence with 284 and Kimuli Joseph with 112.
Dissatisfied with the results, Nsanja petitioned the High Court under Section 80(1)(a) of the Parliamentary Elections Act, accusing the Electoral Commission’s Kayunga Returning Officer of manipulating results from 15 polling stations in Kangulumira Sub-county to favour Baseke.
He argued that the alleged irregularities had deprived him of victory, claiming that his own tally placed him at 15,050 votes against approximately 10,418 for Baseke.
Nsanja also accused the Electoral Commission of failing to ensure the secure handling, transportation and delivery of election materials from the affected polling stations to the district tally centre.
However, Baseke and the Electoral Commission rejected the allegations, maintaining that the results had been properly verified and declared. They argued that the commission’s certified declaration of results forms were authentic, while the alternative results sheets presented by the petitioner were neither authenticated nor reliable.
Presiding officers disown signatures
In resolving the dispute, Justice Mwaka relied heavily on the testimony of three presiding officers who denied signing declaration of results forms submitted to court by the Electoral Commission.
Kacucu Ahamada, who supervised voting at Nakirubi Trading Centre (A-K), told court that the signature appearing against his name on the disputed declaration of results form was not his. He also challenged the document for incorrectly spelling his name as “Kaccucu”.
Namale Nsereko Sumaya, who presided over Nazigo Town Secondary School, and Ssebagala Latib, the presiding officer at Bukasa Church of Uganda Primary School, similarly disowned signatures attributed to them on the respective results forms.
The three officials maintained that they had not authored or signed the documents, despite the Electoral Commission presenting them as certified true copies.
Justice Mwaka observed that their evidence carried considerable weight because they were the officials directly responsible for supervising the voting process and completing the declaration of results forms at the respective polling stations.
The judge also dismissed the respondents’ argument that the presiding officers were prohibited from disclosing information obtained in the course of their official duties under Section 7(6) of the Parliamentary Elections Act.
He reasoned that the disputed documents had already been released into the public domain by the Electoral Commission and that questioning signatures allegedly forged on official election documents did not constitute disclosure of protected information.
“Inevitably, the Court finds to its satisfaction … non-compliance in the Transmission of accurate and verifiable election results and in the subsequent Tallying exercise for the Three (3) Polling Stations,” Justice Mwaka ruled.
Disputed votes exceeded winning margin
The court further established that the results recorded on the three disputed declaration of results forms represented a combined 1,457 votes, more than twice the 611-vote margin by which Baseke defeated Nsanja.
At Nakirubi Trading Centre, the disputed form indicated that 588 voters had cast their ballots, with Baseke receiving 493 votes against Nsanja’s 65.
At Nazigo Town Secondary School, 466 votes were recorded, of which Baseke obtained 348 while Nsanja received 115.
At Bukasa Church of Uganda Primary School, the declaration of results form indicated 403 votes, with Baseke securing 365 against Nsanja’s 18.
The judge held that the irregularities were substantial enough to affect the overall election outcome, particularly given the narrow difference between the two leading candidates.
However, the court did not accept all the allegations raised by Nsanja, dismissing his complaints relating to the remaining 12 polling stations after finding that the evidence presented was insufficient to establish electoral malpractice.
Justice Mwaka observed that complaints by polling agents about missing signatures, disputed entries and alleged misplacement of names were not, by themselves, sufficient grounds to invalidate results, particularly where other election officials and agents had endorsed the declaration forms.
He also declined to rely on alternative declaration of results forms presented by Nsanja because they had not been certified by the Electoral Commission.
The judge said the petitioner had failed to establish the origin, authenticity and chain of custody of the documents, noting that he should have taken steps to obtain their certification from the commission.
The court equally questioned the reliability of handwriting expert reports submitted by the petitioner, finding inconsistencies in the findings and inadequate supporting evidence linking the examined specimens to the disputed documents.
Justice Mwaka particularly cited a report dated March 31, 2026, which contained findings on a presiding officer’s disputed signature that did not correspond with the portion of the declaration of results form identified in the report.
Despite dismissing the wider allegations of manipulation across 15 polling stations, the judge concluded that Nsanja had established electoral non-compliance in the three polling stations, which was sufficient to invalidate the election.
The decision overturns Baseke’s victory and returns Ntenjeru County South to another parliamentary election, with the Electoral Commission now required to organise a fresh poll.
Nsanja petitioned Baseke and the Electoral Commission. He was represented by Ambrose Tebyasa, Ssemanda Ben Zziwa and Ankunda Paul Mugisha.
Baseke was represented by Ahmed Mukasa Kalule, Aaron Buyinza, Ismail Kibirige and Swaibu Mpungu, while the Electoral Commission was represented by Richard Brian Kabayiza.































