Wednesday, November 18, 2026
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact
Insight Post Uganda
  • Home
  • NewsHot
    • Health
    • Politics
    • Religion
    • Lifestyle
    • World News
    • Tourism
    • Environment
    • Agriculture
  • Business
    Court Awards Former Henkel Polymer Employee More Than Shs98 Million for Unfair Dismissal

    Court Awards Former Henkel Polymer Employee More Than Shs98 Million for Unfair Dismissal

    Igara Growers Tea Factory Board Suspended From Company Operations Amid Leadership Dispute

    Industrial Court Awards Former Igara Growers Employee UGX 745,000 Over Unfair Dismissal

    Jamil Kasajja

    Town Clerk Denies Extorting Shs15 Million from Job Seeker

  • Sports
    Uganda Set To Complete AFCON 2027 Stadia By December 2026

    Uganda Set To Complete AFCON 2027 Stadia By December 2026

    Eurofoam Marketing Manager Claire Kemigisha buys the first jersey from Mukono Diocese Bishop Enos Kagodo to launch the Mukono Cathedral Run

    Mukono Diocese Turns To Community Run To Raise UGX5 Billion For Cathedral

    Rogers Sebyondwa

    Bulemeezi Player Dies After Suffering Injuries In Kyaggwe Masaza Cup Match

  • Education
    Gulu University's main campus in Laroo-Pece Division, Gulu City, where university officials and security agencies are seeking measures to improve student safety.

    Gulu University Seeks Museveni’s Intervention to Revive Stalled €155m Teaching Hospital Project

    Parents Demand Answers as Four Pupils Die at Kisaasi School

    Parents Demand Answers as Four Pupils Die at Kisaasi School

  • In Luganda
    Betty Nambooze, Mukono Municipality MP

    Kibuule Akubye Mu Nambooze Ebituli, Talina Kyakoledde BannaMukono Okujjako Okujoboja

    Omubaka Gwetwalonda Teyadda-Abekyampisi Betondedde Kibuule

    Omubaka Gwetwalonda Teyadda-Abekyampisi Betondedde Kibuule

    Counsel George Musisi ng'alaga emu ku kaadi mu lukungana lw'amawulire

    Munnamateeka Wa NUP Atambula Nju Ku Nju Ng’ Asaggula Obuwagizi  

  • In Photos
    Ronald Kibuule at Mukono recently.

    Kibuule Poised for Return as Museveni Signals Endorsement in Mukono North

    Katikiro presiding over the opening of the renovated official residence of the Buddu County Chief at Ssaza grounds in Masaka City on Tuesday. Pictures by Robert Nsubuga.

    Pictorial:  Katikiro Mayiga Slams Masaka People Over Poor Hygiene

    Ismael-Kifudde-the-Mukono-Police-Division-Officer-in-Charge-directing-Nambooze-not-to-use-the-route-heading-to-town-center

    Moments of Excessive Force Against Betty Nambooze in Recent General Elections

  • Profiles
    Akena Calls for Honest Political Dialogue, Accuses NRM of Undermining Electoral Fairness

    Akena Calls for Honest Political Dialogue, Accuses NRM of Undermining Electoral Fairness

    Rwakakooko before PAC

    Parliament Questions UEDCL Preparedness After Umeme Takeover

    Brig. Gen. Kiyengo (center) posing for the photo with the members of Nakifuma Rotary Club who promised to attend his book launch.

    CUTTING THROUGH HELL: UPDF Medic Chronicles Uganda’s Silent War in Somalia Through Powerful Memoir

  • Op-Ed
    • Editorial
    • Opinion
  • Login
No Result
View All Result
Insight Post Uganda
Home Editorial

Court of Appeal Frees Two Men Jailed 45 Years for Murder Over Doubts in Identification Evidence

Insight Post Uganda by Insight Post Uganda
June 27, 2026
in Editorial
Reading Time: 4 mins read
A A
0
Court of Appeal Frees Two Men Jailed 45 Years for Murder Over Doubts in Identification Evidence

The Court of Appeal has overturned the murder convictions of two men who had been serving 45-year prison sentences, ruling that the evidence used to identify them as killers was unreliable and failed to meet the standard of proof required in criminal cases.

Ngabirano Moses and Barahukwa Richard had been convicted by the High Court in Kabale in 2022 for the murder of Bukabeba Benson and each sentenced to 45 years in prison.

Related posts

Courtroom gavel

Court Reduces Murder Sentence Over Sentencing Errors

May 29, 2026
Courtroom gavel

Court of Appeal Overturns 49-Year Jail Term, Orders Fresh Trial

May 20, 2026

In a unanimous decision, a panel of Court of Appeal judges comprising Justices F.M.S. Egonda-Ntende, Oscar John Kihika and Jesse Byaruhanga-Rugyema found that the prosecution had failed to prove beyond reasonable doubt that the two men were among the attackers.

The judges held that weaknesses in the identification evidence, coupled with the prosecution’s failure to produce the first police report and call the investigating officer as a witness, rendered the convictions unsafe. The two men had been convicted and sentenced by High Court Judge Moses Kazibwe Katvumi on May 6, 2022.

Court records indicate that Benson was killed on the evening of November 9, 2017, at Karukara Cell in Hamurwa Town Council, Rubanda District. Prosecutors alleged that the deceased had been involved in a longstanding land dispute with Barahukwa, who is the father of Ngabirano, and that threats had been made against him before his death.

According to evidence presented at trial, Benson and another man, Samwiri Tukamushaba, were walking home from Karukara Trading Centre at about 7:30 p.m. when they were ambushed. Tukamushaba was injured in the attack while Benson sustained multiple cut wounds and later died. A post-mortem examination attributed his death to sharp force trauma and severe blood loss.

The appellate judges found significant weaknesses in the prosecution’s case, which largely depended on Tukamushaba’s testimony as the sole witness identifying the accused.

They observed that the attack occurred at night under difficult conditions and that Tukamushaba himself had been assaulted and injured during the incident. The court noted that two defence witnesses testified that shortly after the attack, Tukamushaba told them he had not recognised the assailants.

The judges said this contradiction cast doubt on the reliability of his later testimony identifying the appellants as the attackers.

They also faulted the prosecution for failing to present the first report made to police after the incident and for not calling the investigating officer to testify. According to the court, these omissions left unanswered questions about whether the witness had identified the accused persons at the earliest opportunity.

While acknowledging that evidence of a land dispute and prior threats could establish a possible motive, the court emphasised that motive alone could not prove participation in the killing.

The judges further ruled that the trial court had not adequately considered the alibi defences raised by the two appellants, noting that the burden remained on the prosecution to disprove an alibi beyond reasonable doubt.

After reviewing the evidence, the Court of Appeal concluded that the prosecution had failed to establish beyond reasonable doubt that Ngabirano and Barahukwa were among the assailants.

“The conviction was unsafe and occasioned a miscarriage of justice,” the judges held.

Having quashed the convictions, the court said it was unnecessary to determine whether the 45-year sentence imposed by the High Court was excessive, since the sentence automatically fell with the overturned conviction.

The two men were ordered to be released immediately unless they are being held in connection with any other lawful charges.

Tags: Court of Appeal
ShareTweetPin
Previous Post

Uganda Moves to Separate Aviation Oversight from Airport Management

Next Post

How Uganda’s Youth Are Rewriting Journalism, One Short Video at a Time

Related Posts

Prof Gordon Wavamunno
Editorial

Supreme Court rules heir qualifies as bona fide occupant after inheriting father’s land interest

November 17, 2026
Augustine Tukei, a police officer attached to Natete Police Station
Editorial

Court Remands Police Officer, Teacher Over Forged UNEB Appointment Letters

November 16, 2026
Mercy Walukamba
Editorial

High Court Dismisses Walukamba’s Petition Challenging Bugweri Woman MP Nankwanga’s Election

November 16, 2026
IG Gives 33 Defaulters January Deadline to Pay Shs1.689 Billion in Plea-Bargain Balances
Editorial

IG Gives 33 Defaulters January Deadline to Pay Shs1.689 Billion in Plea-Bargain Balances

November 13, 2026
Kingfisher Oil Project Moves Closer To First Oil As CPF Pre-Commissioning Ends
Editorial

Uganda’s Oil Revenue at Risk Over Cost Recovery, Weak Tax Framework – NRGI

November 13, 2026
HIV Prevalence Drops to 5.9%, Minister Babalanda calls for UGX 15 billion to strengthen HIV prevention and national coordination
Editorial

HIV Prevalence Drops to 5.9%, Minister Babalanda calls for UGX 15 billion to strengthen HIV prevention and national coordination

November 12, 2026
Next Post
Mulinde Innocent

How Uganda's Youth Are Rewriting Journalism, One Short Video at a Time

RECOMMENDED NEWS

Bishop Dr Samuele and Pastor Margaret Lwandasa attending Easter Service at Mt. Lebanon Christian Centre Catherdal -Mukono

Bishop Lwandasa Condemns Rising Violence, Corruption in Easter Message

8 months ago
Coffee

Racing Against Time: Uganda’s Challenge With EU Coffee Regulations

2 years ago
DPP Opposes Bail Application for Lawyer Eron Kiiza

DPP Opposes Bail Application for Lawyer Eron Kiiza

2 years ago
Dan Odongo, the Executive Director of UNEB

UNEB Awaits Judiciary’s Decision on Specialized Courts to Handle Exam Malpractice

2 years ago

FOLLOW US

Insight Post Uganda

We bring you the most balanced news professionally investigated by our news team. The Insight Post is Uganda’s News company regulated by the Uganda Communications Commission.

Follow us on social media:

Recent News

  • Court Awards Former Henkel Polymer Employee More Than Shs98 Million for Unfair Dismissal
  • Industrial Court Awards Former Igara Growers Employee UGX 745,000 Over Unfair Dismissal
  • Town Clerk Denies Extorting Shs15 Million from Job Seeker

Category

  • Agriculture
  • Business
  • Editorial
  • Education
  • Environment
  • Health
  • Lifestyle
  • Luganda
  • News
  • Opinion
  • Photos
  • Politics
  • Profiles
  • Religion
  • Runyankole
  • Security
  • Sports
  • Tourism
  • Uncategorized
  • World News

Recent News

Court Awards Former Henkel Polymer Employee More Than Shs98 Million for Unfair Dismissal

Court Awards Former Henkel Polymer Employee More Than Shs98 Million for Unfair Dismissal

November 17, 2026
Igara Growers Tea Factory Board Suspended From Company Operations Amid Leadership Dispute

Industrial Court Awards Former Igara Growers Employee UGX 745,000 Over Unfair Dismissal

November 17, 2026
  • About
  • Advertise
  • Careers
  • Contact

© 2024 The Insight post Uganda - The Insight post uganda. Site Powered by Bookablehood Ltd.

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In
error: Content is protected !!
en_USEnglish
en_USEnglish
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Politics
  • Business
  • Sports
  • Lifestyle
  • Tourism
  • Opinion

© 2024 The Insight post Uganda - The Insight post uganda. Site Powered by Bookablehood Ltd.