The Industrial Court has awarded a former employee of Igara Growers Tea Factory Limited UGX 745,000 in compensation after finding that the company failed to observe key procedural requirements during his dismissal over 878.8 unaccounted-for bags of fertiliser.
However, the court rejected the bulk of his compensation claim, ruling that his own admission to signing blank fertiliser delivery notes amounted to a fundamental breach of his employment contract and justified his summary dismissal.
In an award delivered on November 17, 2026, Justice Anthony Wabwire Musana, sitting with panelists Adrine Namara, Susan Nabirye and Michael Matovu, held that although the factory had sufficient grounds to dismiss the employee, it failed to adequately explain his rights during the disciplinary process.
The case arose from a labour dispute filed by Ayebazibwe Delmas, who had worked for Igara Growers Tea Factory since 2007, initially as an Estate Herdsman before being promoted to Field Extension Officer in 2013.
The dispute followed an internal audit conducted in November 2017, which reportedly established that 878.8 bags of NPK fertiliser issued for distribution to farmers could not be accounted for.
The factory subsequently suspended Ayebazibwe on January 31, 2018, for two weeks on half pay and summoned him to appear before its Disciplinary Committee on February 14, 2018.
During the disciplinary process, Ayebazibwe submitted a written defence in which he admitted signing three empty delivery notes at the request of a storekeeper.
He explained that the storekeeper had asked him to sign the documents because of a fertiliser shortage, indicating that the forms would later be completed. He also alleged that the storekeeper had subsequently given him six Form 4 books and asked him to generate farmers’ garden numbers to account for the missing fertiliser.
Ayebazibwe maintained that he refused to participate in the proposed arrangement after discovering further irregularities involving his Movement Issue Vouchers (MIVs) and delivery notes.
The factory’s Disciplinary Committee reportedly found him responsible for failing to account for the fertiliser and recommended his summary dismissal. He was subsequently dismissed on February 26, 2018, and his salary payments stopped in March of the same year.
Aggrieved by the decision, Ayebazibwe challenged his dismissal, arguing that the factory had denied him a fair hearing and failed to establish his involvement in the alleged fraud.
He also accused the company of failing to respond to several communications seeking clarification about his employment status.
His lawyers argued that the disciplinary process was fundamentally flawed because he was only asked to write a statement without being given an opportunity to question witnesses or call people who could support his defence.
They further argued that the internal audit report was inconclusive and had recommended additional investigations, which were allegedly never conducted.
Ayebazibwe also pointed to criminal proceedings instituted against him before the Chief Magistrates Court of Bushenyi, which were subsequently dismissed for want of prosecution.
He asked the Industrial Court to award him UGX 88.46 million in compensation, comprising notice pay, lost earnings, severance allowance, unremitted National Social Security Fund (NSSF) contributions and general damages. He also sought interest at 20 per cent and costs.
However, Igara Growers Tea Factory, through its lawyers, maintained that the dismissal was justified because the employee had been implicated in the disappearance of the fertiliser and had admitted signing blank delivery documents.
The factory argued that it had notified him of the allegations, invited him to a disciplinary hearing and given him an opportunity to present his defence.
It also maintained that the dismissal of the criminal case did not amount to a finding that he was innocent or invalidate its internal disciplinary proceedings.
Court finds procedural lapses
In determining the dispute, the Industrial Court examined whether the dismissal was both procedurally and substantively fair.
The court acknowledged that the factory had taken some steps towards complying with the law by issuing a written suspension letter, specifying the allegations and giving Ayebazibwe 14 days to prepare for the disciplinary hearing.
However, Justice Musana observed that the invitation letter merely instructed him to return on February 14, 2018, prepared to undergo a fair hearing without explaining the specific rights available to him during the proceedings.
The court said the employer was required to inform him of his right to respond to the allegations, be accompanied by a representative, cross-examine witnesses, call his own witnesses and present his case before an impartial disciplinary committee.
It found that the failure to communicate these rights in writing rendered the disciplinary process procedurally unfair.
The court relied on Section 65 of the Employment Act and the First Schedule, which require employers to ensure that employees facing disciplinary action understand the allegations against them, the nature of the proceedings and the opportunity available to prepare and present their defence.
Employee’s admission justified dismissal
Despite finding procedural shortcomings, the court held that Ayebazibwe’s own written admission established misconduct serious enough to justify his dismissal.
The court noted that he had acknowledged signing three empty delivery notes and conceded during cross-examination that he had done so without properly accounting for the fertiliser transactions.
It ruled that the admission amounted to evidence of fraudulent conduct and a fundamental breach of the employment relationship, which depends on mutual trust, honesty and good faith.
The court further observed that an employee’s clear admission of misconduct could dispense with the need for additional proof of the admitted wrongdoing in disciplinary proceedings.
Consequently, it rejected the argument that the factory could not dismiss him because witnesses had not testified against him during the disciplinary hearing.
On the criminal proceedings, the court explained that workplace disciplinary processes and criminal prosecutions are separate legal processes governed by different standards of proof.
It held that an employer does not have to wait for the conclusion of criminal proceedings before taking disciplinary action, provided the employee is accorded a fair hearing and the misconduct is established to the required standard.
The court found that Igara Growers had proceeded with its internal disciplinary process alongside the criminal case and that the subsequent dismissal of the prosecution for want of prosecution did not invalidate the employment decision.
Court rejects Shs88m compensation claim
On remedies, the court ruled that Ayebazibwe was entitled to compensation for the factory’s failure to comply with the statutory hearing requirements, notwithstanding the substantive justification for his dismissal.
Citing Section 66(4) of the Employment Act, which provides for payment equivalent to four weeks’ net wages where an employer fails to comply with the hearing requirements, the court awarded him UGX 745,000.
However, it rejected his other claims, including notice pay, severance allowance, lost earnings, NSSF contributions and general damages.
The court reasoned that awarding further compensation would effectively reward an employee whose admitted misconduct had fundamentally undermined the employment relationship.
In its final orders, the court directed Igara Growers Tea Factory to pay Ayebazibwe UGX 745,000, dismissed the remainder of his claim and made no order as to costs.
The award was signed and delivered electronically in Kampala on November 17, 2026, by Justice Musana.






























